Throughout the years so many minds (including my own) have been captivated by the idea of a utopia, a perfect society where all individuals coexist in perfect harmony. I personally envision a decentralized collective of complete individuals, so perfect in their choices and ethics they are all pure products of rationality. But if each person was to be completely rational and to know that every one else would act completely rationally, then in every single situation there would only be one rationally perfect choice and action for each person and they would all know what it was simultaneously. In such a society, the bounds of individual choice would become one with complete rationality such that, paradoxically, to be completely individual to the full extent of your rational capability would be synonymous wit acting in complete unison with the collective. Identity would cease to exist and experience would become undifferentiated and simultaneous.
In the event of such a paradox I am inclined to assume that a utopia such as I imagine is impossible or if not, it exists at the point where excitement and boredom become identical and so, while perfect, it must be incredibly boring (especially since one would have no self and experience nothing by virtue of knowing everything what everyone and everything will do at all points in time). I guess the only rational decision of the perfectly rational individual/collective would be to become less rational again...
How about a brave new world type scenario? You assume such a society, where there is only one proper choice for any action would be a boring one. I think it's possible though for people to still be happy in such a society, even if it's a kind of happiness which is far from one you or I can imagine, even if it's a disturbing happiness from our perspective. Might not the frictionless cooperation between all be a point of elation, which, being all pervasive, grounds an ever-present sense of ecstasy? (The concept of) identity in such a place would be very different than our own. It may be something akin to Chinese identity, i.e. collectivism, or nationalis, (or fascism). Epsilons are happy to be cogs in the machine!
ReplyDeleteI think from your perspective (and certainly from mine as well) that such a society ceases to be composed of human beings. In which case, boredom is not what we're worried about.
Agreed. I used the term boredom for lack of a better term (and to be slightly humorous), but you nailed what I was going for though. I always enjoy daydreaming of the human race moving towards a utopia consisting of more and more frictionless cooperation between individuals. Throughout such a process, the state of ecstasy would steadily increase as inter-human conflict and oppression dwindled. The vision is beautiful.
ReplyDeleteHowever, it would be exactly as you say. If such a state were to actually be achieved then individual identity would become synonymous with perfect collectivism. Human beings would be perfect and would function without rational volition, being as controlled by the laws of physics as inanimate objects are. When identity and change cease then so does experience. Moreover, the concept of an ever-present state (in this case ecstasy) is a contradiction in terms since a state is by nature temporary. Thus the arrival at utopia must coincide with the eradication of identity, choice, and feeling, the very things that make us human. So basically, I wholeheartedly agree, such a society would not be composed of "human beings "and thus utopia and human beings are not compatible.
Maybe utopia is the non-attainable state of perfection that permits this state of imperfect existence to be experienced by contrast. Or maybe its a bunch of horse shit...