A philosophy of freedom and the freedom to philosophize.

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Philosophy – What's the damn point?

The common response to this question is the cliché, "if you have to ask, you're in the wrong field." Nothing could be farther from the truth. The reality is that if you do not have to ask, you're in the wrong field. In fact, "what's the damn point?" is the first question that any philosopher should ask.
If there was no point, no practical application to philosophy then the field as a whole should be abandoned. Luckily for philosophers, and all people are philosophers whether or not they realize it, philosophy serves a necessary and practical purpose: making sense of the world.

5 comments:

  1. The name of the day is practicality. You know, what practical advantage does studying X give me over studying Y. Practicality: simply another name for utilization and exploitation. Medicine, engineering, economics and theose other so-called practical sciences are the already-fabricated aim based activities that dictate what's a legitimate and what's an illegitimate way of life. Practical means you can get a job. It means you'll be accepted into the system, that the system knows how to make sense of you, and that you've learned how to make sense of the system. The practical arts, those whose worth is taken as self-evident, are the furthest from the question "what's the damn point?" This of corse is tragic. For we need economics and medicine. Knowing we need them though does not permit us to forget why we need them; for happiness, for the experience-machine that is life, for inter/intra-personal love, whatever you'd like to call that thing for which you live.

    'What's the damn point' (Wtdp) though requires courage. It requires an openness to change, to saying past habits are no longer true for what I must do now. Wtdp is standing on a speeding train, by an open door. It's the cool anxiety of considering a jump, with only the vague impression that there'll be another train to pick you up and take you where you're going. Wtdp is the first step. There's a reason people don't like philosophy.

    p.s. Will, I support your decision to make a philo. blog. I may have one coming my way too. Much Love, I

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amazing Isaac, beautifully said! Moreover, you elegantly pointed me to an error I made in my post, namely not drawing the distinction between the common (and utterly flawed) conception of practicality and my (our conception) of practicality. Too often practicality refers to the system of compromises that most make to obtain the status and possessions dictated by our twisted society, leading practicality to be synonymous with the slow and volitional death of an individual's psyche. This conceptual manipulation leads people astray from a mindset where practicality does not mean what is useful in molding to the masses but what is useful in one's achievement of a successful life. Again, our formulation of success has also been perverted to mean the attainment of many goods and status as opposed to the simple concept of living a happy and fulfilling life.
    This response is too well written and insightful for me to not repost it as a standalone post. I want this blog to be a discussion, especially if it is approached with openness and intelligence such as this post (which is not surprising, coming from you). If you start a blog, I want to be the first one to know and until then feel free to contribute!
    One love homie!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also if you (or anyone else reading this) would like to post something and its not in relation to anything yet posted, or you feel it is significant enough to stand on its own, email it to me, and I can post it as a lead instead of as a comment. I would really like this blog to be more of an open forum than just me standing on a soapbox.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think a redefinition of the term 'practical' is essential to what you're trying to achieve with this blog. The question one should always ask him(her)self is: practical to what end? or To whose end? Often people tell me, having heard I studied philosophy, that I'll never find a job, that I, like all the philosophically inclined, tend to overcomplicate and get nothing done. It's the same old de-contextualized, oversimplified quote of Marx, the point of philosophy (thinking) is not to interpret the world, the point is to change it. Well, to use the term 'practical', and argue about what (how) we ought to do, without questioning "what's the damn point?" is to miss the first step. You've gotta think/question/talk before you can know what you want, or why you want to change the world, or how you're going to do it, or who is going to help you? Practicality=movement toward a successful/chosen/human life. Great.
    -I

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey, I thought you and I were supposed to disagree all the time?! lol! I hear the same thing all the time: what is the end game? The funny thing is that I/we actually have an answer, "to make sense of ourselves and the world in which we exist in such a way that we can make the choices that allow us to live the happiest life we can achieve."
    Meanwhile turn the question on them and ask them by what means they achieved their "practical ends." I always just sit back and listen to the answers, "I compromised all my values so my boss would favor me or I threw away all of my hopes in dreams to follow a socially acceptable path." Of course, people never actually say those things aloud because they somehow believe you can achieve ends without a means. Still, a denial of the significance of means is implicit in the actions of every person who asks how philosophy can be useful. If only those people realized that one of the ends of philosophy is to figure out how to avoid degrading means that lead to such meaningless ends...

    ReplyDelete